Why long-term investing success is about time in the market, not timing
It is only natural that investors would want to find some way to sit out bear markets and get back just in time for the next bull run. The belief that you can foresee the direction of the stock market is a seductive one.
Some investors are confident that they can time it perfectly and snap up equities when prices are low and shift into cash or bonds when the market hits its peak. But investors run a big risk by selling when they believe stocks have reached their peak. They may turn a profit when cashing in their equity holdings, but they could also miss out on some of the market’s best cycles. Being absent from the market for only a few of the days or weeks with the highest percentage gains can decimate a portfolio’s returns over time.
Market timers who sell frequently also lose money to transaction costs and taxes and miss out to a large extent on the compounding effect that benefits investors who remain in the market consistently. Instead of trying to time the market, most investors are generally better off taking a buy-and-hold approach – but with the right investments.
Gains in Year One
Looking at the distribution of market gains coming off of the past 7 bear market cycles, we see that on average, 64% of the gains were captured in the first 6 months of year one. But that’s not to say that gains were absent in the next 6 months – the gains just slowed down.
Bear Market Bottom Gain in 1st Year of Rebound Percentage of Gains in First 6 Months Percentage of Gains in Last 6 Months
1970 32% 13% 87%
1974 38% 90% 10%
1982 59% 66% 34%
1987 23% 80% 20%
1990 31% 92% 8%
2002 32% 31% 69%
2009 71% 73% 27%
2020 47% ? ?
Average 41% 64% 36%
Source: S&P 500 total returns, Morningstar. Past performance does not guarantee future results. 2020 return period from March 23, 2020 through September 25, 2020
Will 2020 be Different?
No one knows. But consider that coming off of the 2020 bear market bottom, the S&P 500 returned 47% from March 23rd to September 25th. Maybe in another six months we will look back and recognize that those first 6 months off of the 2020 bear market bottom captured 92% of the gains, just like what happened in 1990.
Or maybe we will realize that those first 6 months only captured 31% of the gains, like in 2002.
Where Should You Go from Here?
Trying to pinpoint the exact right time to invest in the stock market is an exercise in futility. If you have a longer period to invest, owning equities provides one of the most effective hedges against inflation and taxation available. Since it is impossible to know where the market might go from here, it makes sense to start investing now and continue investing on a regular basis, regardless of market conditions.
Remember: long-term investment success is achieved not by timing the market, but by time in the market.
Content in this material is for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.
All investing involves risk including loss of principal. No strategy assures success or protects against loss.